“If figuring out how to deal with the SEC on crypto issues feels like a regulatory version of an escape room, here’s the latest clue,” wrote one of the agency’s own Commissioners last week on Twitter. It wasn’t the first such salvo by Commissioner Hester Peirce—known to many as “crypto Mama”—and it’s unlikely to be the last.
For Peirce, the SEC’s latest misstep—the one that drew the “escape room” snark—was a bloated piece of legalese the agency coughed up last Monday in response to broker-dealer firms that wanted to branch out to sell security tokens. The document, a joint release from FINRA, explained how a regulation called the Customer Protection Rule made such sales a non-starter for now. While Bitcoin and Ethereum are in the clear (the SEC has said they are not securities), brokers who want to sell other popular tokens—such as Tezos or EOS or Dash—remain in limbo .
According to SEC staff, the trouble lies in the fact that brokers can’t protect digital assets in the same way they safeguard other customer investments. While brokers can comply with the Protection Rule by parking clients’ stocks and bonds with a bank or trust company, the same option doesn’t exist for security tokens. As the regulators note, it’s hard to prove someone else doesn’t have the private key to a stash of crypto—and if the stash is hacked, unlike a stock certificate, there is no way to recover it. Hence, the SEC’s slow-rolling when it comes to letting brokers sling security tokens.
“It’s a frustrating process for all involved. The SEC is saying ‘we’re not in the solutions business, but this is the problems you guys have to solve,’” says Phil Liu, a lawyer and co-founder of Arca, an investment management firm for crypto assets.
Liu adds the problem is unlikely to get cleared up soon, especially as, unlike stock certificates, many crypto assets are unique, and require extra effort from any would-be custodian that wants to store them. Meanwhile, insurance companies are not familiar enough with digital assets to back-stop brokers in the event they get hacked.
In light of all this, it’s not surprising the SEC shrugged its shoulders when it came to helping brokers sell crypto assets. But it’s also understandable why Peirce describes the agency’s approach to crypto as an “escape room”—a confusing set of riddles and dead-ends. While countries like Switzerland are actively promoting a crypto eco-system, the leading U.S. financial regulator is telling companies when they may get sued, but doing little to create rules that could help them.
So how could the SEC do better? I will put the question directly to Commissioner Peirce when she joins me on stage on Tuesday morning at Brainstorm Tech in Aspen. If you have other questions for Hester Peirce, feel free to email them to me. If you didn’t make it Aspen, you can check out our livestream here—”Crypto Mama” goes on stage Tuesday at 11am MT/1pm ET.
Send feedback and tips to email@example.com, find us on Twitter @FortuneLedger or email/DM me directly at the contact info below. Please tell your friends to subscribe.
Jeff John Roberts
THE LEDGER’S LATEST
Visa Pours Millions Into Cryptocurrency Startup Anchorage by Robert Hackett
YouTube Adds More Pay Features to Its Free Video Service by Danielle Abril
Stripe Outage Smacked Business for Two Hours by Julie Verhage
Checkout Startup Bolt Raises $68 to Help Retailers Take on Amazon by David Z. Morris
To the Moon… Bitcoin ATMs are blooming in PA convenience stores. Investment firm offers to pay $900 per Bitcoin to Mt. Gox creditors. SEC blesses Blockstack’s token security offering. New one-stop crypto investment shop from Bitmain’s Jihan Wu is up and running. Coinbase looks to get into the insurance business. Sanction-wrecked Iran may give crypto mining a try. Winklevoss twins let bygones be bygones, say they will try Zuckerberg’s Libra. Trump Bitcoin tweet as “Achievement unlocked!”
…Rekt. The Treasury Secretary thinks virtual currencies are a national security concern. Texas town bets big on Bitmain…and loses. Bitcoin back below $10,000 for a few hours. Ransomware crooks want Monroe College to pay $2 million in Bitcoin to get its files back. Bitmain loses $150,000 in mining misfire.
That’s the average salary for “blockchain-realated” jobs in the U.S. right now, a figure 117% higher than the average American wage of $49,000. This is one nugget from a research report titled “Blockchain’s Got Talent” by research firm Teqatlas. Also of interest are tidbits about the firms with the most blockchain openings (top 5 are IBM, Oracle, PWC, EW and Coinbase), and the university that’s producing the most blockchain executives—take a bow Stanford.
MEMES AND BUBBLES
Testing tribal loyalties. Many crypto fans are clannish types who will defend their favorite coin from all comers—and will do the same when it comes to their political heroes. So what happens when the two loyalties collide? That was the dilemma faced by Trump-loving crypto fans when the President last week dumped on Bitcoin. The response—of course—was a series of memes, including this “Defend Trump vs Betray Bitcoin” tweet.
FOMO NO MO’
Can Libra be like Bitcoin? Don’t count on it. Plenty has been written about Facebook’s wildly-ambitious crypto project, but Tim Lee of Ars Technica has one of the better answers to “can this possibly work?” Lee is skeptical, noting that the Libra crowd wants to enjoy all the permissionless perks of Bitcoin when it comes to regulation—while also having central control. The upshot could be ugly:
“You could wind up with a network where would-be payment app developers have to do stacks of paperwork before they can write their first line of code, where small organizations struggle to get approval to create Libra-based services, and where the functionality of services is constrained by legal requirements.”